Skylines and Stories

Last week, the Atlantic Cities published an article that tries to explain “what your skyline says about your city.” The assumption is that different types of skylines convey different meanings, and cities should be aware of that process. So, for example, the “power broker” skyline

is tall and robust, and represents everything that we imagine when we think of skylines. New York, Tokyo, and Chicago are prime examples, all featuring a good mix of residential and commercial buildings, and a heterogeneous architectural fabric, indicative of a constantly evolving urban landscape.

The article features nine other skyline “categories” along with descriptions of the underlying messages they convey.

It’d be generous, though less and less inaccurate, to say that Provo has a skyline. Indeed more and more tall (or tall-ish) buildings are going up or being planned all the time. At this stage, however, the “message” Provo’s skyline conveys is still probably yet to be written. If anything, the many large cranes over the city and the relative newness of the tall buildings make Provo seem like something of a boomtown.

Over the long term, I see Provo’s skyline resembling Paris or Rome more than New York. Though those European cities are grouped into the “zoned out” category, their defining feature in my experience is the frequency of low- to medium-rise buildings.

In other words, neither of those cities — as well as others in Europe — have many of the massive structures that characterize American, Middle Eastern and Asian metropolises. Despite or, research increasingly suggests, because of the lack of super-tall buildings European cities manage to blend density with things like high quality of life and mixed use development. The European model seems fitting for Provo for those reasons, and because medium-sized buildings are cheaper to erect than ultra-tall skyscrapers.

But whatever the future holds, it’s important to consider now what kind of message the community wants to convey with its skyline.

Provo’s skyline is only in its earliest stages. Still, it’s worth considering not only what Provo should be like in the future, but also what its skyline says about the city.



Filed under building, construction

2 responses to “Skylines and Stories

  1. Logan

    I see only one crane and no tall (or tallish buildings) a 10 story building is not tall. try 30 or 40 and that’s a tallish building. And to call provo a city is kinda weird considering it’s more like a town. “Downtown” Provo consists of 4 blocks. You seem to be really into architecture and I’m wondering why are you living in a dumpy little town like Provo? Move to a really big exciting city where you can be around the things you like! big buildings! and lots of them. Me personally I can’t wait to get out of this crazy town

    • Again I don’t understand why you’re reading this blog or living in Provo. This comment is insulting; I’m clearly writing as someone who thinks Provo has potential. If you disagree there’s not much for us to talk about. Also, it’s insulting because if you just clicked over to the home page you would know that the blog is not active any more and I don’t live in Provo. I’m kit sure which is worse, that you’re another person who believes in the idiotic cliches about Provo, or that you felt entitled to comment on this blog after reading so little of it. Do your homework and let those of us who want to make our community better — whatever it might be — do that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s